Bottles with Browning

Viticultural Profile

At the one French collection where the Bordeaux red varieties are grown side by side, Cabernet Sauvignon buds eleven days after Merlot and ripens three to three and a half weeks after the reference variety Chasselas. It is not, however, the last of those varieties to ripen, and the official French c

Cabernet Sauvignon · Foundations

What you will be able to do

Most descriptions of Cabernet Sauvignon in the vineyard are written from the wine backwards. It makes tannic, long-lived wine, so the vine is described as late, small-berried and hard to ripen, and the description is arranged to explain the wine.

The official French catalogue of vine varieties, PlantGrape, maintained by the IFV and INRAE, works the other way. It records what has been measured, in one place, on one method, over decades. It is less flattering and considerably more useful, and on several points it does not say what everybody says.

How the catalogue measures a vine's calendar

PlantGrape does not publish harvest dates. It publishes offsets, and it states why:

Every variety is grown together at the Domaine de Vassal collection at Marseillan, in the Hérault, on the Mediterranean coast. Each one's budbreak and maturity are recorded against a single reference variety, Chasselas B, so that the numbers can be compared across years and across sites.

Chasselas B's own reference points at Vassal are 17 March for débourrement and 12 August for maturity, each of them a seventy-year mean.

Budbreak: the eleven day gap

Here are the five varieties, side by side.

Cabernet Sauvignon is the last of the five to bud, and not narrowly. Thirteen days against Merlot's two puts an eleven day gap between the two most planted Bordeaux reds, and eight days between Cabernet Sauvignon and Cabernet Franc.

That eleven day gap is the cleanest single number in this lesson: one site, one method, one reference variety.

Ripening: not what you would guess

Now the maturity column, and it does not behave.

Cabernet Sauvignon is not the last of the five to ripen. Petit Verdot is. Three and a half to four weeks after Chasselas against Cabernet Sauvignon's three to three and a half. The variety that buds second earliest of the five finishes last.

Cabernet Sauvignon does ripen later than Cabernet Franc, but the ranges overlap. Three to three and a half weeks against two and a half to three. They meet at three weeks. The defensible statement is "later, on overlapping ranges", not "much later".

Carmenere ripens earliest of the five, at two weeks, despite budding eight days after Chasselas. Nothing on the page explains that compression, and this lesson will not invent an explanation for it.

And the Merlot comparison, carefully. Merlot is two and a half weeks, Cabernet Sauvignon three to three and a half. Subtract the ranges and the difference is half a week to a week. That subtraction is ours. PlantGrape publishes two ranges, not a day count, and you should quote it as the difference between two stated ranges rather than as a published figure.

The vine itself

PlantGrape's agronomic paragraph is worth having in full:

Unpacked:

Notice how little the catalogue is willing to join up. It attaches the trellising need to the long shoots and the labour cost to the hard wood, and it leaves the other three traits standing on their own. It does not, for instance, say that lignified tendrils are why removing the wood is slow, however plausible that sounds when you have tried to pull a Cabernet Sauvignon cane out of a wire.

The same restraint applies to the instruction to avoid large pruning wounds. That sentence sits in one paragraph and the note about trunk diseases sits in the next, and PlantGrape draws no line between them. The connection is the first thing a modern viticulturist would reach for. It is not what the source says.

Soil

One sentence, and it is more specific than its reputation:

Four attributes: gravelly, free-draining, rather acid, well exposed. And a hedge, le plus souvent, most often. It is a statement of tendency, not a rule.

The third attribute is the one to hold onto, because it is the one that goes missing. Gravel and drainage are quoted everywhere. Plutôt acides, rather acid, almost never survives translation.

What the catalogue does not offer is any mechanism. No heat retention, no root depth, no water stress, no vine balance. Those explanations may well be right, but nothing in this lesson's sources supports any of them, and a viticultural profile that hands you an unsourced mechanism is worth less than one that hands you four measured attributes and stops.

What it gets ill with

Read the strength of each claim exactly.

Grey rot, pourriture grise, is moindre sensibilité: lower susceptibility. Lower than other varieties, not immune, not resistant. The thick-skinned-so-it-never-rots line overstates what the catalogue actually says by a full step.

The trunk diseases run the other way, and hard. Très sensible, very susceptible, to eutypiose and esca, and to oïdium, powdery mildew. The OIV's own varietal profile agrees independently, describing Cabernet Sauvignon as particularly susceptible to trunk diseases and to powdery mildew, and it adds a third trunk disease, excoriose, that PlantGrape does not list. Two bodies agreeing on trunk disease and powdery mildew is about as firm as this kind of claim gets. The third name belongs to the OIV alone and should be attributed that way rather than folded into a single list.

There is also a disorder: the vine is parfois sujet au dessèchement de la rafle, sometimes subject to stem desiccation, and the catalogue says the risk is increased by certain rootstocks, naming SO4.

Small, and what small means

PlantGrape says, flatly, les grappes et les baies sont petites: the bunches and berries are small. Berries are round.

That would be a useless sentence except that the same page publishes the scale it is using. For wine varieties:

So "small" is a defined band, not an impression: a bunch of 100 to 200 g and a berry of 1.5 to 2 g. The table carries a separate column for table varieties with different bands, so the class has to be read in the right column.

What the catalogue does not publish, anywhere, is a skin thickness, a skin-to-pulp ratio, a seed-to-pulp ratio or a measured berry weight for this variety. The famous line about Cabernet Sauvignon's thick skins and high skin-to-pulp ratio has no figure behind it in any source used for this lesson. If you want to make the argument, make it from the size band, which is published, and say so.

The official record

The regulatory part of the record is drier than the agronomy, and it contains the best single fact in this section.

Eighteen clones of Cabernet Sauvignon are approved in France: 15, 169, 170, 191, 216, 217, 218, 219, 267, 269, 337, 338, 410, 411, 412, 685, 1124 and 1125. Behind them sits a conservatory collection planted in the Bordeaux vineyard holding more than 250 clones, gathered from prospecting carried out between 1966 and 1988.

The catalogue prints a line or two against individual clones. Nine of those entries were read for this lesson, and two of them are remarkable:

Two long-standing approved clones, 191 and 337, carry leafroll virus 2, enroulement in the catalogue's French. The official catalogue says so in public, and it lists alongside them the two clones that were produced to replace them, 1124 out of 191 by microgreffage d'apex, apex micrografting, and 1125 out of a different sanitary family of 337. That is a national variety register documenting its own problem and its own fix on the same page, and it is a better illustration of what clonal selection actually is than any amount of discussion of clone numbers in the abstract.

No synonym is officially recognised. The catalogue is explicit:

Set that against the previous lesson. The Vitis International Variety Catalogue records 62 synonyms for Cabernet Sauvignon, and they collide hopelessly with Cabernet Franc's and Carmenere's. Faced with that, the regulatory answer is to recognise none of them. There is one official name, hyphenated, Cabernet-Sauvignon, on list A of the French catalogue and classed. Besides France it is registered in the catalogues of Germany, Austria, Bulgaria, Cyprus, Spain, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Malta, Portugal, the Czech Republic, Romania, Slovakia and Slovenia.

And the area, which has a shape.

Roughly 7.7 times more Cabernet Sauvignon in 2008 than in 1958, and then a fall of 12,634 hectares, about 21 per cent, in the ten years that followed. PlantGrape offers no explanation for the fall. The variety's French area peaked in 2008 and had come down sharply by 2018. That is the fact.

What this hands to the next lesson

One paragraph of the PlantGrape page looks forward rather than back:

Tannic structure, deep colour at good ripeness, suited to ageing and to oak, vegetal aromas giving way to more complex ones, and a want of flesh and roundness when vinified alone. The OIV records the same four observations independently: high tannin, deep colour, good ageing potential with vegetal flavours fading, and a wine that is not particularly round or fat.

Two things to carry forward. The first is that the aroma shift in that paragraph is conditional on ripeness. Lorsque la maturité est satisfaisante, when ripeness is satisfactory. The OIV puts the same condition the other way round, noting the pyrazines are present if the grapes are harvested early. Neither source gives a threshold, and neither explains what causes under-ripeness. The condition is the point, not the decoration.

The second is that last clause. Vinifié seul, vinified alone, the variety often lacks flesh and roundness. The official French catalogue of vine varieties says that about one of the most admired red grapes in the world, in a subordinate clause, without apology.

On yield, finally: the OIV gives a range of 2 to 14 tonnes per hectare depending on vine vigour. That is a world range, not an appellation limit, and it is tonnage rather than hectolitres. The appellation limits, which are a different kind of number entirely, belong to the Left Bank module.

Glossary

Chasselas
The reference variety against which PlantGrape expresses every other variety's phenology. Chasselas B at the Domaine de Vassal buds on 17 March and reaches maturity on 12 August, each figure a seventy-year mean.
Domaine de Vassal
The collection at Marseillan in the Hérault where PlantGrape's phenological observations are made. Because every variety is grown there side by side, the offsets can be compared with one another.
débourrement
Budbreak, the moment the buds open in spring. PlantGrape calls Cabernet Sauvignon a variety with débourrement tardif, late budbreak.
2ème époque
Second epoch, the broad ripening class PlantGrape assigns. All five varieties compared in this lesson sit in it, so the label alone distinguishes none of them from the others.
eutypiose
Eutypa dieback, one of the trunk diseases PlantGrape names Cabernet Sauvignon as very susceptible to.
esca
A trunk disease of the grapevine. PlantGrape names it alongside eutypiose as a disease Cabernet Sauvignon is very susceptible to, and the OIV names it too.
oïdium
Powdery mildew. PlantGrape records Cabernet Sauvignon as très sensible to it, and the OIV calls the variety particularly susceptible to it.
pourriture grise
Grey rot, Botrytis cinerea. PlantGrape gives Cabernet Sauvignon a lower susceptibility to it, which is not the same as resistance.
dessèchement de la rafle
Stem desiccation, a disorder in which the bunch stem dries out. PlantGrape says Cabernet Sauvignon is sometimes subject to it and that certain rootstocks increase the risk.
SO4
A rootstock. PlantGrape names it as one whose use increases Cabernet Sauvignon's risk of stem desiccation. It is named as a risk factor, not as a recommendation.
microgreffage d'apex
Apex micrografting, the sanitation technique by which clone 1124 was produced from the virused clone 191, free of leafroll virus 2.
enroulement
Leafroll. PlantGrape records two approved Cabernet Sauvignon clones, 191 and 337, as carrying leafroll virus 2.

Sources

  1. Cabernet-Sauvignon, fiche variété, PlantGrape, the official French catalogue of vine varieties (IFV / INRAE)
  2. Cabernet franc, fiche variété, PlantGrape, the official French catalogue of vine varieties (IFV / INRAE)
  3. Merlot, fiche variété, PlantGrape, the official French catalogue of vine varieties (IFV / INRAE)
  4. Carmenere, fiche variété, PlantGrape, the official French catalogue of vine varieties (IFV / INRAE)
  5. Petit Verdot, fiche variété, PlantGrape, the official French catalogue of vine varieties (IFV / INRAE)
  6. Focus 2017: Distribution of the world's grapevine varieties, International Organisation of Vine and Wine (OIV)
Open the lesson, with quiz and flashcards →
A lesson from the Bottles with Browning Academy. Free, no account needed.